Consulter Neuvième Art la revue

Orientalism in Marvel’s Moon Knight (1975-2022), from Comics to Disney+

Mémoire par Sébastien - Jacotin
Sous la direction de Delanoë-Brun, Emmanuelle
Master2026- English Studies - Sorbonne Nouvelle
Paris- France

This dissertation studies the evolution of Orientalist representation in Marvel’s Moon Knight from its comic-book debut in 1975 to the Disney+ miniseries released in 2022. Drawing on Edward Said’s Orientalism and Ella Shohat and Robert Stam’s concept of polycentric multiculturalism, it examines how Egypt and the broader Middle East are represented across the comics written first by Douglas Moench and later by authors such as Jeff Lemire. The analysis shows that Douglas Moench’s Moon Knight in the early 1980s frequently relies on Orientalist conventions, including exoticized settings, reductive Arab figures, and stylized Egyptian imagery, whereas the comic-book iterations of the 2010s begin to revise these patterns within a publishing landscape shaped by the late 1990s publication of Joe Sacco’s influential postcolonial graphic novel Palestine. The most substantial corrective occurs, however, off the comic-book page in the 2022 Disney+ miniseries Moon Knight, which, in the context of Disney’s diversity and inclusion policy, grants Egypt greater visual and narrative centrality and foregrounds Arab voices and contemporary Cairene life. Yet the miniseries remains marked by residual Orientalist tropes and raises the question of whether an adaptation of an Orientalist comic can ever be fully de-Westernized. Rather than wholly escaping these visual and textual stereotypes, the miniseries aligns with polycentric multiculturalism, significantly reworks earlier misrepresentations, and points toward a tentative postcolonial, Egyptian-centered fantastical mode emerging today in the art and literature of both the Middle East and the West.

 

memoire-m2-s.-jacotin-diff-jake-atone.pdf Télécharger - 8.64 MB